Behind the Screen - Swarm Rule Adjustments
Hello & Welcome!
When the heroes were adventuring deep inside Jarlmoot, they faced several different smaller enemies as part of solving the puzzles before they took on the big baddie.
One of those enemies were a pair of Swarm of Ravens.
We had not previously played with the Swam mechanic and as written, the rules mainly focus on certain damage resistances (piercing, slashing, bludgeoning) and this makes sense as trying to stab at one of the swarm elements would of course do less damage and as the Swarm's HP diminishes, then so does the damage that they do (since there are less of them). This is all well and good and logical when considering we try to apply a certain level of "realism" into the game.
The other core mechanic of course is that the Swarm can.occupy the same space as another character or creature. This too of course makes perfect sense. And this is as far as the rules as written generally go.
So we got to thinking how would we manage this situation with a little more realism - what would we consider would reasonably happen wen Characters try to deal with the Swarm.
What we agreed on was that if a Swarm is occupying the space of another creature (like a fellow Party member), then when another creature (another fellow Party member) tries to help their friend and attacks the the Swarm with their weapon then they are effectively targeting the same physical space as the other creature.
Ideally the Swarming creatures would be hit and if the Attack roll succeeds, then yes, the Swarm loses HP. But, if the Attack roll fails, then what we felt was reasonable was that there would be a chance that the missed swing would hit the other creature. Its like the blade swinging past the flapping Ravens and instead potentially connecting with the Fighter being Swarmed.
So we tweaked the rule a little bit to address this situation:
- When you make an attack roll against a swarm that is occupying another creature's space and miss the swarm, roll a d6. On a 1, you accidentally strike the creature sharing the swarm's space instead. The creature takes half the attack's normal weapon or spell damage. Additional optional damage such as Sneak Attack, Divine Smite or similar effects is not applied.
- A natural 1 on the original attack roll always triggers the d6 roll.
- Before making the attack, you may choose to attack cautiously. The attack is made with disadvantage, but you cannot accidentally hit the creature within the swarm.
- This rule applies to melee attacks, ranged attacks and single-target spell attacks that require an attack roll. Area effects are resolved normally.
We felt this gives an extra little twist to the Swarm mechanic and adds an extra element of risk and realism.
It was used in that session and as it happened one of the Player Characters damaged their companions and in doing so provided a little extra fun for role play between the players.
We will surely use it again when they come across such enemies again as it turned out to be quite a fun little twist.
Why not give it a try in you next session?
Until next time, thanks and happy painting and happy gaming!
-Pete (& Mitz & Simz)
If the cold wilds of Icewind Dale have your Party Swarmed and scrambling, these might find a natural home at your table:
Swarm of Ravens by MZ4250 · Raptor Swarm Big by Epic Miniatures
The party plays custom-printed heroes - get your own made:
Or explore more designs to fit this setting in Aberrations!.
Leave a comment
All comments are moderated before being published.